SCHOLARLY OR POPULAR?#
colorful, flashy colors single color (although may have other colors with the advent of new publishing techniques)
illustrations/graphics charts and diagrams, and not photos
advertisements table of contents on cover
widely available textual
general/generic titles fewer advertisements and more scholarly in nature
intended for general audience limited audience
catchier article title focused title, may include words journal, review, annals
  long titles
lower reading level higher reading level, assumes prior knowledge
  specialized language
staff writers/ maybe not identified authored articles, many times more than one person
  editorial /advisory board
sometimes opinion usually based on research
paid articles means of passing on research and means of communication with colleagues
good point for beginning research  
no bibliography footnotes and bibliography
  review of the literature
  article begins with abstract







Scholarship or Propaganda ?

Definitions
propaganda



Checklist of scholarship and propaganda*
Propaganda Scholarship
operates either many levels of both truth and falsehood Strives for truth and admits weaknesses
Presents one point of view as the only point of view presents other points of view and may include dissenting points of view
Misleads deliberately Attempts to be fair-minded and admits bias or viewpoint
Manipulates charts, graphs, statistics to support a premise Interprets data carefully whether they support of refute a premise
Provides ready-made answers and solutions to problems Invites critical analysis
Results in changed attitude and /or motivation to action to be successfu Invites continuing research









Adapated from:

*Bodi, Sonia, "Scholarship or propaganda; how can librarians help undergraduates tell the difference?" Journal of Academic Librarianship 21(Jan. 1995):21-25.

#Fink, Deborah. Process and Politics in Library Research: A Model For Course Design. Chicago: American Library Association, 1989.